How Many Estimates Should I Get for a Siding Project?

Replacing your home’s siding is a significant investment that affects both your property’s protection and curb appeal for decades. While it’s tempting to go with the first contractor who provides a quote, or conversely, to collect estimates from every company in the Portland-Vancouver area, finding the right balance is key to making an informed decision without overwhelming yourself in the process.

The Sweet Spot: 3-4 Estimates

Industry experts and homeowners who’ve been through the process generally agree that obtaining 3-4 estimates provides the optimal balance. This range gives you enough data points to understand market pricing, compare different approaches, and evaluate contractors without creating analysis paralysis. With three to four estimates, you’ll likely see patterns emerge in pricing and recommendations while still maintaining a manageable decision-making process.

Getting fewer than three estimates risks missing out on better pricing or superior solutions. However, pursuing more than four rarely adds value—you’ll often find the additional quotes fall within the range you’ve already established, while consuming valuable time for both you and contractors who ultimately won’t get your business.

What Quality Estimates Should Include

A professional siding estimate should be comprehensive and detailed. Look for estimates that clearly specify the scope of work, including removal and disposal of old siding, any necessary repairs to sheathing or structure, and the installation process itself. Material specifications should be exact—not just “vinyl siding” but the specific manufacturer, product line, thickness, and warranty details.

Timeline information is crucial, including start date, expected duration, and how weather delays will be handled. The estimate should break down costs clearly, showing materials, labor, and any additional services separately. This transparency helps you understand where your money goes and makes it easier to compare proposals accurately.

Quality contractors will also include information about their warranty coverage, both for materials and workmanship. They should detail what preparation work is included, such as wrapping windows and doors, installing house wrap or moisture barriers, and handling trim work.

Red Flags That Should Raise Concern

Beware of estimates that seem too good to be true—they usually are. Extremely low bids often indicate corners will be cut, inferior materials used, or surprise charges added later. Vague estimates that lack detail about materials or processes make it impossible to know what you’re actually paying for and leave room for disputes later.

High-pressure tactics are another warning sign. Legitimate contractors understand that siding replacement is a major decision requiring careful consideration. If someone insists you sign immediately for a “special price” or claims the estimate is only valid for 24 hours, look elsewhere. Quality contractors respect your need to compare options and make an informed decision.

Watch out for contractors who request large deposits upfront or want payment only in cash. Established companies have material supplier relationships and don’t need significant customer deposits to begin work.

Making Your Final Decision

Once you have your estimates, create a simple comparison chart. List each contractor with their price, warranty terms, timeline, and included services. This visual comparison helps ensure you’re evaluating equivalent proposals—one contractor’s lower price might exclude services others include.

Remember that the lowest price isn’t always the best value. Consider the contractor’s reputation, experience with homes like yours, and the quality of materials they’re proposing. A slightly higher price for better materials or more experienced installation often pays dividends in longevity and fewer problems down the road.

Pay attention to your interactions with each contractor. Were they punctual for the estimate appointment? Did they thoroughly inspect your home and ask relevant questions? Did they explain their recommendations clearly and answer your questions patiently? These behaviors often predict how they’ll handle your project.

The Hometown Exterior Designs Difference

At Hometown Exterior Designs, we believe in providing detailed, transparent estimates that help homeowners make confident decisions. We welcome comparison shopping because we know our combination of quality materials, expert installation, and comprehensive warranties stands up to scrutiny. Our estimates include everything needed for a successful siding project, with no hidden surprises.

We understand that choosing a siding contractor is about more than just price—it’s about trusting someone with your home’s protection and appearance. That’s why we encourage getting multiple estimates and taking time to make the right choice. When you’re ready to include us in your estimate process, we’ll provide the detailed, professional proposal you need to make an informed decision about your siding project.